↵ select ↓ ↑ navigate esc close

Paper Feed: An Alternative to the Desktop Metaphor

Paper Feed ·

Listen: https://serve.buildtall.systems/90a00f9b7ae9f6d7bfa2b58fb1d5f4ae6d98211c1b483343c7e453a242702dca.mp3

Source: https://serve.buildtall.systems/260c3f7ebf7d5bfeba3cdbe91cbb779f3d9e233b129b52e151a3e80869c759d6.pdf


An Alternative to the Desktop Metaphor is a paper by Scott Fertig, Eric Freeman, and David Gelernter of the Department of Computer Science at Yale University. It describes a system called Lifestreams, which the authors propose as a replacement for the familiar desktop metaphor and for conventional files and folders. The paper argues that managing one's electronic world has become frustrating for most computer users. People must juggle too many separate applications, move files between them, translate formats, invent pointless names, and build organizational hierarchies. The authors say what is needed is a metaphor for organizing the electronic bits of paper we all collect, whether they arrive as email, downloaded images, web pages, or scheduling reminders. Lifestreams, they argue, is such a system: a fluid and natural way to organize electronic documents that reflects how users actually work. This episode covers the opening portion of the document as extracted.

At the center of the proposal is the basic model. A lifestream is a simple organizational metaphor: a time-ordered stream of documents. It replaces conventional files and directories. Stream filters and software agents organize, locate, and monitor incoming information. The authors claim Lifestreams subsumes many separate desktop applications for common communication, scheduling, and search and retrieval tasks. Its architecture is machine-independent and client-server, and it is open so that users can continue to use the document types, viewers, and editors they are accustomed to.

The paper describes a lifestream as a diary of your electronic life. Every document you create is stored in your lifestream, as are documents other people send you. The tail of the stream holds the past, perhaps starting with an electronic birth certificate. Moving toward the present, the stream contains more recent documents such as papers in progress or the latest email. Pictures, correspondence, bills, movies, voice mail, and software are stored in between. Moving beyond the present into the future, the stream contains documents you will need: reminders, calendar items, and to-do lists.

The Lifestreams interface shows a stream of documents. The user can slide the mouse pointer over document representations to glance at each document, or use a scroll bar to roll back into the past. The paper describes several visual cues. Unread documents have colored red borders; writable documents have thicker borders; open documents are offset to the side to show they are being edited. Incoming documents slide in from the left to alert the user, and newly created documents pop down from the top and push the stream backwards by one document into the past. In this way documents are eventually moved out of view and archived automatically. The lifestream also contains a future portion that is accessible but usually hidden. A clock displays the current time and can be temporarily reset to the future. Users can deposit notes in the future as reminders. When the clock is reset to the present, those notes are hidden again, but they arrive on the stream at the appropriate time to remind the user.

Users interact with Lifestreams through five primary operations: new, clone, transfer, find, and summary. New and clone create documents. New creates an empty document and adds it to the stream. Clone duplicates an existing document. Transfer copies a document from your stream to someone else's. Find prompts the user for a search query and creates a substream. Summary distills a large number of similar documents into a single overview document. The content of that overview depends on the type of documents in the substream. If the substream contains daily closing prices of all stocks and mutual funds in an investment portfolio, the overview might display a chart of historical performance along with net worth. If the substream contains a list of tasks, the overview might display a prioritized to-do list.

The paper asks why Lifestreams is needed. It cites studies showing that users of common desktop systems have difficulty with several things: organizing information, making effective use of it, discarding it, finding archived information without becoming overwhelmed by hierarchical structure, getting a big picture view, and managing schedules and reminders. Lifestreams is offered as an answer to these difficulties.

A key idea is substreaming. Substreams provide an organizational framework and an inexpensive way of finding information. Like virtual directories, they present a view of a document collection; in this case, all documents relevant to a search query. They differ from conventional directory systems because they do not place documents into fixed file and folder structures. Instead, they create virtual organizations of documents from the stream. Documents are not actually stored in the substream; the substream is a temporary collection of documents that already exist on the stream. Substreams may overlap. They can be created and destroyed on the fly without affecting the organization of the stream or any existing substream. If a substream is allowed to persist, it will collect new documents that match the search criteria as they are added. For example, a substream created with the query find all documents created by other people would subsume your mailbox and automatically collect mail as it arrives. A substream created from all electronic mail I haven't responded to would act as a mailbox containing only unanswered mail. Substreams can be created incrementally, yielding a nested set of menus. The paper says that semantically this incremental substreaming amounts to a boolean and of each new query with the previous substream's query.

In conclusion, the paper argues that computer users must deal with a far greater quantity and range of electronic objects in their work and personal lives than before. New systems must efficiently support a document-centric model in which documents are the sun around which applications revolve. Lifestreams takes this a step further by embodying in software a more fluid and natural model of the electronic office. It replaces the desktop metaphor with filters, summaries, agents, and a time-ordered stream. Menus are used to choose among existing substreams, create summaries, and reset the system clock into the past or future. By default, Lifestreams presents the user with a view of the stream from the present, receding into the past. The extracted text stops at that point, so this episode has covered the opening portion of the document.

  1. An Alternative to the Desktop Metaphor