↵ select ↓ ↑ navigate esc close

Paper Feed: Stoic Philosophy of Mind

Paper Feed ·

Listen: https://serve.buildtall.systems/ababd33a14ea2160cfa8deb4f0f05759374336cab09f0b7b0bf3c8c875455f92.mp3

Source: https://serve.buildtall.systems/11d7c9f9295b620100ad440438975c05e144af5671ad15dd6a24de4847e03fec.pdf


This episode covers Stoic Philosophy of Mind, an entry published by the Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy and dated November 23, 2020.

This entry is a survey rather than a study with new data. It asks whether the ancient Stoics had anything like a philosophy of mind, given that the Greek idea of the soul, the psuchê, is broader than the modern mind and was never treated as a separate field. The author works through the three parts of the Stoic system, Physics, Logic and Ethics, and reconstructs their views on the soul as a physical, breath-like substance called pneuma, on perception and assent, on memory and concept formation, on impulse and action, and on the passions. The method is interpretive. The evidence is ancient testimony and fragments, which the entry reads closely and compares with Plato, Aristotle and modern debates. The entry is published by the Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy and is dated November 23, 2020. Its strengths are its coverage of the whole system and its care with technical terms. It also flags where the record is thin, such as the account of how the reproductive faculty relates to the commanding faculty, where the entry says little survives, and Chrysippus's answer to how presentations are retained, which the entry itself calls a far from satisfying solution. The front matter and passages state no funding or data disclosures. According to OpenAlex, no work in the index matches this document's title and authors, as of October 11, 2026. OpenAlex therefore has no record of the document, and this episode makes no claim about how often it has been cited.

The first thing to notice is that the ancient Greeks and Romans did not treat philosophy of mind as a separate field. Still, the questions we now file under that heading, including perception, imagination, thought, emotion, memory, personal identity and action, were routinely discussed under the title Peri psychês, or On the Soul. The survey this document offers draws out the Stoic ideas about the soul and related topics that roughly line up with present-day philosophy of mind.

The author begins by pointing out that the ancient Greek idea of the soul is very different from the modern idea of the mind that grew out of Descartes. Today, we tend to set mind against body, and when we say mind we mean mainly our cognitive abilities and perhaps our sense of who we are. The Greek soul is much broader and is tied closely to the basic workings of the body. The document describes it as "first and foremost the principle of life," the thing that animates the body. The same soul accounts for our capacity to think, perceive, imagine and reason, and it is also responsible for respiration, digestion, reproduction, growth and movement. According to the document, the closest ancient thinkers come to a Cartesian view of the soul are Plato, the Pythagoreans and their successors. Stoic psychology sits at the opposite end of that range. It offers what the author calls "a corporeal or physicalist model of soul," meaning the soul is itself a physical thing.

Because Stoicism has no single subject that matches modern philosophy of mind, the author says the evidence has to be gathered from several parts of the Stoic system. The Stoics divided philosophy into three parts: Physics, Logic and Ethics. Teaching about the soul turns up in all three. In Physics, the Stoics examined what the soul is made of, how it relates to God and the cosmos, and what role it plays in the working of the human body. In Logic, they built a theory of meaning and truth, and that theory depends on an account of perception, thought and other mental concepts. The document says that here the Stoics "developed a sophisticated theory of mental content and intentionality," and also worked through the ontological consequences of that theory. In Ethics, they developed a detailed account of emotion and a psychology of action, which had a large influence on their moral philosophy. As the author puts it, the growth of a person's cognitive faculties was thought to be inseparable from ethics. The conclusion the document draws is that Stoic psychology was central to Stoicism as a whole.

Zeno of Citium, the founder of Stoicism, lived from about 335 to 263 BCE and was already very interested in the nature of the soul. The article reports that he and his student Cleanthes, who lived from about 331 to 232 BCE, stressed how active the mind is by identifying it as "an internal fire or vital heat." Stoic psychology did not reach its mature form until Chrysippus, who lived from about 280 to 207 BCE. According to Chrysippus, the human soul consists of "a breath-like substance called pneuma," and the cognitive faculties are identified with the specific activities of that pneuma.

Pneuma did more than make up individual souls. It was also the organizing principle of the whole cosmos, a world-soul that the Stoics identified with God or Zeus. The article describes one ancient source that pictured God as "an intelligent, artistic fire that systematically creates the cosmos as it expands." In the same passage, God is called a pneuma that pervades the whole cosmos, just as the human soul pervades the mortal body. The result, as the article puts it, is that the Stoics saw the world as a living organism, which sets their view apart from contemporary physics and cosmology.

The article stresses that

Stoic psychology is inseparable from Stoic physics and cosmology.

The pneuma of the human soul, which the Stoics called pneuma psychikon, is said to be a mixture of air and fire. Some Stoics took the soul to be a literal mixture of fire and air. Others linked it to a refined fire, similar to aether, which in older Greek thought was the pure substance of the heavens, or to vital heat. The body's pneuma was seen as a portion of the divine pneuma that permeates and directs the cosmos. In the article's words,

The human soul is a portion of God within us, both animating us and endowing us with reason and intelligence.

On the question of what the soul is made of, the article says that

The Stoics argued that the soul is a bodily (corporeal) substance.

It adds a caution, however: "it is best to avoid calling Stoic psychology materialist." The reason is that the Stoics contrasted soul and matter, so modern scholars usually prefer words such as corporealist, physicalist, or vitalist. For the Stoics, a body is anything that occupies space and has causal power.

The article explains the Stoic account of principles. Every bodily substance is built from two principles. The passive principle is matter. The active principle, which the article gives in Greek as to poioun, is reason, or logos, which it identifies with God. This active principle extends through matter, supplying motion, form, and structure. The article insists that

Both principles are bodily or corporeal principles (that is, they occupy space and are causally efficient) but neither exists in isolation.

Any given substance can be dominated by one principle or the other, and the article gives the rule plainly: "the more active the substance, the more rational and divine it is; the more passive, the more material."

The Stoics also distinguished principles, called archai, from elements, called stoicheia. The basic elements are earth, water, air, and fire. Earth and water are heavy and passive, dominated by the passive principle. Air and fire are active and closely tied to sentience and intelligence. The Stoics held that the soul is nourished by exhalations from the passive elements. Living bodies, the article notes, differ from non-living ones by a specific kind of activity, which comes from the presence of the active elements within the body.

The section turns to pneuma, which the account calls the central theoretical tool of both Stoic physics and Stoic psychology. Pneuma is a stuff often translated as breath or spirit. The Stoics set themselves against the atomists here. Where the atomists held that the world is made of particles separated by empty space, the Stoics argued for a continuum theory that denied the existence of void in the cosmos. In their picture,

The cosmos was seen as a single continuum of pneuma-charged substance.

What makes one thing differ from another, on this view, is how the pneuma moves through it. The account says that the qualitative difference between substances, such as between a rock and a pool of water, is determined by the degree of tensional motion of the pneuma pervading each substance. Tensional motion, in the Greek tonikê kinêsis, is a movement of the pneuma that runs from the center of a body to its surface and back again at the same time. Earth and water are passive elements with a low degree of this tensional activity, while fire, air and the soul show a high degree. The payoff, as the account puts it, is that the concept let the Stoics build one physical theory on pneuma that could still tell organic from inorganic things. So, in the account's words, "Stoic physics showed that there exists a physical connection and continuity between mind and matter."

The organizing idea here is the scala naturae, a ladder or hierarchy of powers in nature, ranked by how active and well organized the pneuma is in a thing. At the bottom, pneuma produces simple cohesion, holding a unified body together. The Stoics called this state hexis, or cohesive state. Wood and stones are examples. Even these stable objects, the account notes, have an inner flow of pneuma, so that "even the most stable object possesses internal motion according to the Stoics."

A higher degree of pneumatic activity produces phusis, or organic nature. Things with phusis grow and reproduce, but show no sign of cognitive power. Plants are the clear case of something that has both hexis and phusis but no soul. Each level on the ladder includes the power below it.

The next tier is soul, psuchê, marked by impulse and perception. Non-rational animals have hexis, phusis and psuchê together. At the top, only human beings and gods have reason, logos. The account defines reason as a collection of conceptions and preconceptions, and says it is especially marked by the use of language. The difference between animal and human thinking, the account suggests, lies less in speaking aloud than in thought having a syntactic and propositional structure, like language. Parrots can articulate human sounds, but that does not make them reasoners. For the Stoics, "thinking in rational animals" is a form of internal speech.

The account warns against confusing this scheme with Aristotle's hierarchy of the soul, which it resembles in some respects. The Stoic ladder covers inorganic substances as well as living ones, while Aristotle's is limited to biological organisms, and it rests on a very different idea of soul.

The physics behind Stoic psychology has some striking consequences. Active substances, the Stoics held, can pervade passive ones, and so the soul, which is itself a body, can pervade the physical body. The soul does not sit in the body the way water sits in a sponge, filling gaps between its parts. The account says the Stoics held that "the corporeal pneuma occupied the exact same space as the passive matter", so that the two are mutually coextended, a relation the Greek calls antiparektasis. The soul permeates the body in the way heat pervades an iron rod, occupying the same space while remaining qualitatively distinct. The Stoics called this kind of mixture crasis, or total blending.

The account sets total blending against two other kinds of mixing. In particulate mixture, such as a jar of mixed seeds, each seed stays unchanged and only the arrangement differs. In fusion mixture, the ingredients are physically altered and a new substance appears, as when eggs, milk, yeast and flour become bread. In total blending, by contrast, the blended substances, such as water and wine, keep their properties and could in principle be separated again.

The account flags a particularly controversial claim. For mutual coextension, the two bodies need not be equal in quantity. Chrysippus, it notes, provocatively argued that in total blending "a drop of wine could pervade (coextend through) the entire ocean." This is an explicit rejection of Aristotle's theory of mixture in his work De generatione et corruptione. It also shows how elastic the Stoic pneuma is: active substances can exist in a very rarefied form and still keep distinct properties.

The Stoics' doctrine of pneuma and total blending let them take over Plato's definition of death as

the separation of the soul from the body.

They turned that definition against him. Only physical things can separate from physical things, they argued, so if the soul can separate from the body, the soul must itself be corporeal. The soul pervades the body as a mixture of the kind called crasis, and that is what makes separation possible. The separation, the entry suggests, comes through a loosening of the soul's tension. Sleep is a mild relaxing of that tension. Death is a total relaxing, and it is this that results in the soul's departure from the body.

Dying, on this account, does not end a person's existence. Once the soul has separated from the body, it keeps its own cohesion for a period of time. Chrysippus and Cleanthes disagreed about what follows. Cleanthes held that the souls of all men could survive until the conflagration, "a time in which the divine fire totally consumes all matter." Chrysippus held that only the souls of the wise are able to endure. The souls of the unwise, in his view, exist for a limited time before they are destroyed or reabsorbed into the cosmic pneuma. The souls of irrational beasts are destroyed along with their bodies.

The entry then makes a point that bears on the wider ethics:

In no case is there any indication that the survival of the soul after death had any direct benefit to the individual or that the Stoics used this as a motivator toward ethical or intellectual behavior.

Survival after death, in other words, is not offered as a reward or a threat. Stoicism has no heaven or hell, and the work of living well and perfecting one's virtues belongs to the present.

The Stoics held that the soul has a specific structure, and that structure helps explain its capacities. The text puts it this way: "the soul consists of eight parts which are spatially recognized portions or streams of pneuma." Pneuma is the breath-like stuff the Stoics took the soul to be made of. The eight parts are the five senses, which the text lists as sight, vision, smell, taste and touch, plus the reproductive faculty, the speech faculty, and the central commanding faculty, which the Greek calls the hêgemonikon. Every one of these parts is an extension of pneuma that starts in the hêgemonikon.

The author uses several analogies to picture this arrangement: the soul is like an octopus, a tree, a spring of water, and even a spider's web. The octopus, tree and spring stress that the soul is one unified thing, with its individual powers rooted in or sprouting from the hêgemonikon, which sits in the heart. The text notes that the Stoics, like Aristotle and Praxagoras of Cos, placed the cognitive center in the chest rather than the head.

The author also ties this picture to Stoic views on how a fetus develops. The heart is the first organ of the fetus to function, and the Stoics thought the soul's pneuma begins there and spreads through the body, refining its powers as the fetus grows. On this account, the powers of sense perception, speech and reproduction are extensions of the hêgemonikon's pneuma, and they reach their mature state as the child nears adulthood.

The text compares the Stoic split between the commanding faculty and the outlying faculties to the modern split between the central and peripheral nervous systems. The comparison holds, the author argues, because the Stoics held that higher cognition and all cognitive experience happen exclusively in the hêgemonikon. Aristotle was comfortable saying that touch is felt in the flesh and sight in the eyes. The Stoics said instead that the senses merely report information to the central faculty, "where it is experienced and processed."

To explain how sensation works, the text uses the idea of transmission, in Greek diadosis. One analogy is a king who sends out messengers. The messengers gather information and bring it back to the king, just as the hêgemonikon extends its pneuma to the sense organs, and the pneuma carries what those organs pick up back to the heart. The second analogy is a spider in a web. When an insect disturbs the web, the vibration travels to the spider at the center. In the same way, the soul extends through the body like a sensory grid that creates a tension, or tonos, and all perceptual information travels as a tensional motion, or kinesis tonikê.

For hearing and sight, the medium between the sense organ and the object also works as an extension of the soul's pneuma. The text describes air as holding a degree of tension that a sound disturbs, much as a pebble tossed into a calm pool disturbs the water. The sound spreads through the air in a spherical pattern. When that motion reaches the ears, the body's pneuma picks up the pattern and passes it to the hêgemonikon. Vision works similarly. Pneuma from the eyes meets external light and forms a cone-shaped visual field. That field can detect the shapes of objects within it as though by touch. In fact, the text says, all the senses were thought to be forms of touch. Color was regarded as a kind of surface texture on an object, and each color was thought to produce its own pattern of disturbance in the visual pneuma.

The author notes that these analogies explain the link between the commanding faculty and the senses, but they do not explain the other two outlying faculties, speech and reproduction, as well. The senses are passive. They receive the tensional motion of an object and pass it to the command center. With speech and reproduction the motion runs the other way. Speech is an expression and articulation of the tensional motion produced when thought is formed in the hêgemonikon. The text gives an interesting piece of evidence here. Chrysippus argued that the hêgemonikon is in the heart and not the brain, and his central argument was that speech is produced together with breath.

The reproductive faculty is harder to pin down. The text says that

little survives on how the Stoics viewed the relationship between the commanding faculty and the reproductive faculty.

What the sources do report is that the seed that produces a child is drawn from the whole body of both parents. That differs from the Aristotelian view that the male parent supplies the form and the female parent supplies the matter.

Beyond the eight parts, the hêgemonikon itself has four basic powers: presentation (phantasia), impulse (hormê), assent (sugkatathesis), and reason (logos). The text reports that the eight parts differ in their bodily substrata, while the four powers of the hêgemonikon are told apart by quality, with respect to that same substratum. The author draws the conclusion that "the four powers of the hêgemonikon are not individually isolated in space; their identity seems to be characterized exclusively by their function."

The article then turns from the mind to logic, and the link between the two runs through what the Stoics called the hêgemonikon, the commanding faculty of the soul. Its most basic power is the ability to form presentations, the phantasiai. Mental assent, cognition, impulse and knowledge are all either extensions of presentations or responses to them, so presentations are the raw material for the rest of the system.

The article explains that presentations divide into two kinds. Some are rational. The article says rational presentations are limited to human beings and are called thoughts, noeseis. Like other presentations, thoughts are physical states of the soul-pneuma. What sets a rational presentation apart is its structure. Something is said about something, so the thought has meaning, and if it is a proposition it has a truth value.

For a simple thought expressed in language, the article names three elements: the thing signified, the sound, and the content of what is said. Take the sentence

The cat is black.

The thing signified is the black cat, the signifier is the sounds of the words, and the content is the claim about the color of a specific animal. That content is called a lekton, and the article says it is what can be true or false, not the object or the sound.

It is the lekton that makes the sounds of a sentence to be more than just sounds.

A lekton is not a bodily thing like a thought or the soul. The article says it loosely corresponds to the modern notion of a proposition, a statement, or the meaning of an utterance. It also says the doctrine of lekta has generated much controversy, and that it is an important link between Stoic theory of mind and Stoic logic.

On presentations themselves, the article reports that Zeno defined a presentation as an imprinting in the commanding faculty, much as a signet ring leaves its shape in soft wax. At birth, the commanding faculty is, in the article's phrase, like "a blank sheet of paper which is ready to receive writing," so all cognitive experience is drawn from the senses. Zeno also connected the word phantasia to the word for light, phôs. The article notes that few agree with this etymology, but says it shows Zeno saw two elements in a presentation: the phenomenal experience of its object and its representational content. The Stoics sometimes called the presentation an affection, a pathos, in the soul, which the article reads as stressing that a qualitative experience cannot be separated from the information it carries. In the article's example,

When we see a red circle, we don't just acquire information, we also experience it as a red circle.

Chrysippus was less comfortable with the imprint analogy. The article asks the questions he raised: what kind of imprint a color or a sound would make, and how the pneuma in the chest could hold such a rich store of patterns. He preferred to call presentations alterations of the commanding faculty. He compared this to the same air being altered by many sounds at once while keeping each one distinct. The article is candid that this is "a far from satisfying solution," and it points out that contemporary philosophy of mind still has much work to do on memory and the retention of concepts.

The doctrine of presentation also grounds the Stoic account of memory and concept formation. The Stoics separated presentations that come directly from the senses from those the mind produces out of earlier presentations. Memory, on the article's account, is stored presentations. Conceptions, ennoêmata, are collections or patterns of those stored presentations. Imagination is explained as the manipulation of stored content: taking elements from experience and enlarging, shrinking, transposing or negating parts of them. The article's example is a mermaid, made by transposing a fish's body onto a young woman's torso. Since mermaids do not exist, the article asks how something non-existent can be an object of thought and even produce desire. The Stoic answer distinguishes the imagined object, the phantasma, which here is the mermaid, from the mental construct, the phantastikon, which is the thought of her. The article's point is that we are not drawn to the mental image but "to the intentional object of the idea, namely to the mermaid herself." It notes that similar distinctions were pursued in the early twentieth century by philosophers such as Meinong and Russell.

Having a presentation is not the same as accepting it. The Stoics held that some presentations, the phantasiai, receive assent and some do not. In the document's account, assent occurs when the mind accepts a phantasia as true, or, more precisely, "accepts the subsisting lekton as true." A lekton is the meaning of a sentence, the thing that can be said or thought about the world, as distinct from the spoken or written words. The document stresses that assent is a specifically human activity, tied to the power of reason.

Truth itself is binary, since a proposition is either true or false, but the document notes that there are levels of recognizing truth. Opinion, or doxa, is a weak or false belief. The sage avoids opinion by withholding assent when conditions do not allow a clear and certain grasp of a matter.

Some presentations, however, are strong enough to settle the question. Experienced in perceptually ideal circumstances, they are called kataleptikê, meaning "fit to grasp." The document says these are "so clear and distinct that they could only come from a real object." Such a presentation compels assent through its clarity, and according to some Stoics it serves as the criterion for truth. The mental act of taking hold of truth in this way was called katalepsis, which the document glosses as "having a firm epistemic grasp."

The idea of katalepsis as a firm grasp returns in Zeno's analogy of the fist. According to Cicero, Zeno compared the presentation to an open hand, assent to a hand that begins to close, katalepsis to a closed fist, and knowledge to a closed fist grasped by the other hand. The document cautions that the analogy misleads if read as a sequence of separate processes in time. Katalepsis was defined as a kind of assent, not as a distinct process that follows assent. Knowledge, or episteme, was defined as a katalepsis that is secure and unchangeable by reason. So the point of the fist, in the document's reading, is that "the central powers of the commanding faculty have different and progressively greater epistemic weight." The analogy describes a progression from simple presentations to a systematic coherence of knowledge, with each grasp confirmed by and consistent with other katalepseis. It is not a claim about how the mind's powers are divided into separate parts.

The document presents the emphasis on assent as an important contribution to ancient philosophy. Assent marks that the mind has accepted a presentation, and it allows a person to entertain a thought while still rejecting it. As the document puts it, "philosophical prudence often demands that we withhold assent in cases of doubt." Treating assent as a distinct step gave a plausible account of how someone can consider a particular thought without accepting it.

Assent also matters for action. Presentational content often prompts an inclination to act by representing something as desirable. The Stoics called this an impulse-generating presentation, phantasia hormetikê, and held that it produces an impulse to act. The document describes the impulse as "a sort of call to action which is manifested as a motion of pneuma directed toward the specific organs of action." Pneuma is the breath-like substance that the Stoics believed carried the soul's movements through the body.

The basic function of impulse is to initiate motion. When we perceive an object or event, a presentation forms in the commanding faculty, the ruling part of the mind, and the rational faculty evaluates it. Depending on its content and on the person's conception of what is good, the object is classed as good, evil, or indifferent. The faculty of assent, working with reason, will accept, reject, or withhold judgement according to the object's value. If the object is deemed good, an impulse arises as a motion in the soul substratum. If it is bad, the document says, repulsion, or aphormê, is produced, and the agent withdraws from the object.

Having said that the Stoics held the soul to be free of experiential content at birth, the entry turns to what nature supplies anyway. The Stoics did not think a blank soul ruled out innate characteristics and impulses. The most basic one, on their account, is the impulse toward self-preservation.

This is the primary human impulse and the starting point of Stoic ethics.

Nature implants it, and it carries a certain consciousness of what belongs to the organism and what is alien or hostile to it.

The entry sets this against the Epicureans, who held that the primary impulse was toward pleasure. The Stoics argued instead that the innate impulse toward self-regard and an awareness of one's own constitution was "even more elementary." On this view, the impulse explains how animals naturally know how to use their limbs and defensive organs, and why they naturally recognize predators as enemies.

Children and animals are not rational, so nature must supply the primary impulse as a foundation for behavior. In animals, these innate impulses account for complex behavior that often looks intelligent. The entry offers the spider as an example. The Stoics held that a spider lacks rationality, despite its apparently intelligent use of a web to catch insects. Primary impulses in animals are therefore identified with complex instincts.

In human beings the picture differs.

In the case of human beings, primary impulse is ideally a transitional mechanism.

As children mature, they develop reason, and the impulse toward self-preservation comes under its scrutiny. Reason allows the agent to grasp the notions of duty and virtue, which may at times take precedence over self-preservation. As the agent advances in virtue and reason, children, family members, neighbors, fellow citizens, and finally all humankind come to be seen as intrinsically valuable and part of the agent's sphere of concern. The entry calls this process oikeiôsis, or the doctrine of appropriation, and treats it as central to Stoic ethics.

The entry then turns to the doctrine of preconception, or prolepsis, which it links closely to the primary impulse.

A preconception is an innate disposition to form certain conceptions.

The most frequently mentioned examples are the concept of the good and the concept of God. This fits the blank-sheet view: because the soul is blank at birth, a preconception cannot be a specific piece of knowledge. It can only be an innate disposition to form certain concepts.

The last piece of Stoic philosophy of mind that the article takes up is the doctrine of the passions. To see why the Stoics needed a theory of passion, it helps to start with Plato and Aristotle. They held that the soul had both a rational and an irrational part, and they used that split to explain mental conflict. Their example is the irrational "appetitive part" of the soul, which may crave a steady diet of rich and fatty foods, while the rational part resists, because such a diet is unhealthy. The result is emotional conflict and, in some cases, moral conflict. Most Stoics denied that the soul has an irrational faculty at all. Posidonius is the best-known exception. Even so, the Stoics still had to explain mental conflict, so they built a theory of passion that, in their view, could do the same work as the Platonic and Aristotelian account.

The article notes that the Stoics defined passion in several ways, each stressing a different feature of the term. It gives four common accounts. A passion is an excessive impulse. It is an impulse that disobeys the dictates of reason. It is a false judgement or opinion. And it is a fluttering of the soul, in the Greek word ptoia.

The first two definitions treat passion as a kind of impulse. The first stresses force. A passion is a runaway impulse or emotion. Chrysippus compared a passion to a person running downhill who cannot stop at will, carried along by the sheer strength of the impulse. Passions often build a momentum that is hard to halt. Some texts also add a time dimension. The fresher the passion, the stronger the impulse, and passions usually weaken as time passes.

The second and third definitions stress the logical side of passion. Passions go against reason and rest on mistaken thinking. The author points out that being irrational does not mean coming from an irrational faculty. Passions can be errors made by the rational faculty itself. As the article puts it,

Having a rational faculty does not imply infallibility.

Rather, the rational faculty produces cognitive states through an inferential process that works with something like the syntax of language. Mathematics is a useful comparison. When we make a mathematical mistake, we do not blame some non-mathematical part of the soul. We blame a single, limited, and fallible rational faculty. The Stoics saw passion the same way. Passions are "false judgements or mistakes in regards to the value of something," and so they are misdirected impulses.

The reason these judgements count as mistakes lies in Stoic ethics. Only virtue is truly good. Externals such as wealth, honor, power, and pleasure are morally indifferent, the Greek adiaphoron, because each can also harm us and each ultimately lies beyond our control. They have no bearing on our happiness. When we value something indifferent as though it were a genuine good, we make a false judgement and experience a passion.

The traditional Stoic passions fall into four classes, depending on whether the error concerns good or bad and whether it concerns the present or the future. Mistaking a present non-good for a good gives the passion called pleasure, along with its subspecies. Mistaking a future non-good for a good gives appetite. Mistaking a present non-evil for a bad gives distress. Mistaking a future non-evil for a bad gives fear.

The fourth definition, the fluttering of the soul, is probably a physical description of passion, much as Aristotle described anger as a boiling of the blood around the heart. The Stoics were corporealists, and they often described mental activity in physical terms, as states of the pneuma, the breath-like material that makes up the soul. They defined the individual passions as an irrational swelling or rising, the Greek heparsis. When impulses are excessive and unruly, the pneuma in the chest can feel like a fluttering. By contrast, Zeno described happiness, a state that presupposes rationality and virtue, as a smooth flowing of the soul. The fluttering can also stand for the instability of passions as judgements. Chrysippus illustrated this disruption with Euripides' Medea, who keeps flipping back and forth from one judgement to another.

The article argues that these four definitions agree, even though each stresses a different aspect of passion. Take grief over stolen property, which counts as a passion, a species of distress. The object of concern is of no moral worth, because only the virtuous response to a situation can be morally good or bad. So the impulse behind the grief is excessive. Because the griever ignores the reasoning that happiness lies in virtue alone, the impulse also disobeys reason. Because the value placed on the object does not match its true worth, the grief rests on a false judgement. And the distress shows up not as calm but as a fluttering or disturbance in the soul.

If passions are excessive impulses and mistaken judgements that produce emotional disquiet, then there must also be appropriate impulses and correct judgements that produce emotional peace. The article warns against reading Stoicism as a call to be emotionally flat. In its words, "the goal is not absence of emotion, but a well-disposed emotional life." Such a life has impulses that are rational, moderate, and held in check, and they fit the nature of things, both in the truth of the judgement behind them and in the degree of the response. The Stoics called these positive states the eupatheiai, or good-passions. The author suggests that this label may have been meant to correct the impression that the school had no emotions. Examples include joy, the Greek khara, which is the counterpart of pleasure; caution, the Greek eulabeia, which is set against fear; and reasonable wishing, the Greek boulesis, which is set against appetite. The difference lies in three things. In a eupatheia, the force of the impulse matches the value of the object, the impulse fits rational behavior, and the belief about the object is true.

There are only three eupatheiai, against four passions. No eupatheia corresponds to distress. The article ties this to the Stoic idea of moral invincibility. Distress was defined as a wrong judgement about a present evil. But the Stoics held that the good does not lie in external events or objects. It lies in the virtuous response of the moral agent to any situation. Since a virtuous response is always possible, there is no true evil in the present, and as the article concludes,

The good is always possible here and now.

The main takeaway is that for the Stoics the soul is a body, a fine breath-like pneuma spread through the whole body and tied to the cosmos, so the study of mind cannot be separated from their physics, logic or ethics. Passions are read as false judgements about what is good, and the aim is a well-disposed emotional life rather than the absence of feeling. The entry states its own open questions and limits. The evidence about the reproductive faculty is scarce. The account of how the commanding faculty holds its many impressions remains unresolved, and the entry notes that contemporary philosophy of mind still has much work to do on memory and the retention of concepts. The doctrine of lekta has generated much controversy. The entry also cautions that the fist analogy misleads if read as a sequence of separate processes in time. Survival after death gave no direct benefit as a motivator, so the ethical weight falls on the present. The picture rests on a reconstruction from fragmentary ancient sources, so it should be held as the best available account rather than settled doctrine.

  1. Stoic Philosophy of Mind