↵ select ↓ ↑ navigate esc close

marginal revolution read out: Privatize Air Traffic Control, Redux

marginal revolution read out ·

Listen: https://serve.buildtall.systems/92d4c0c2117ce62cbcc33cbbfa19643995256b7ba7ee79a56b7e496dfbee6d79.mp3

Source: https://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2026/11/privatize-air-traffic-control-redux.html?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_campaign=privatize-air-traffic-control-redux


This is marginal revolution read out, and the post is Privatize Air Traffic Control, Redux. The post opens with yesterday's FAA ground stop: every domestic departure in the United States was grounded for more than four hours. The author notes these events are becoming more frequent; the last nationwide grounding was in 2023, and regional groundings have hit Newark, Dallas, and the entire Northeast in the past two years. The author says an earlier post from October of 2025 was prompted by labor problems and understaffing, but yesterday's failure, according to Transportation Secretary Duffy, was about capital: aging TDM telecom circuits overloaded with data. The deeper cause, the author argues, is poor incentives: airlines bear the costs when the system fails and have almost no say in how it is run. The author anticipates that some will blame a private contractor, adds a pro tip not to update system software on a Friday at three p.m., but insists that contracting out is not the same as privatization. The argument for privatization is to give responsibility to the people who pay when the system fails, aligning incentives. The post reprints the 2025 argument, which notes that America's NextGen has delivered only about sixteen percent of its expected benefits after more than twenty years, years late and over budget.

The first linked item is October of 2025. The text of that earlier post is not available here, but the author's commentary says it was prompted by regional groundings and delays caused by labor problems. Air traffic control was then, and still is today, far understaffed, and the government shutdown hit the controllers the system had, further stressing it. The title points to the earlier argument that today's post revisits.

Next is a post titled grounded flights at Reagan (DCA) from The Master Builder on X. It describes the airspace over Washington pausing mid-motion as the FAA issued a ground stop for Washington National Airport, citing air traffic controller staffing shortages. The post says removing controllers means removing capacity, and that every delayed flight ripples through the Eastern Corridor toward New York and Atlanta. The author's framing is that the FAA grounded flights at Reagan because there were not enough controllers, and by mid-afternoon thousands of flights were delayed nationwide.

The next link is a Forbes report titled thousands of flights. The article text is not available here, but the author cites it for the scale of the disruption: by mid-afternoon, thousands of flights were delayed nationwide, and the same thing was happening at major airports across the country.

Then comes a Fox Business article titled major airports across the country. It reports that three major U.S. airports issued ground stops or delays on a Thursday, all attributed to staffing shortages during the federal government shutdown. Reagan National, Newark, and LaGuardia were the airports named. The article quotes Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy saying that normally five percent of delays are attributed to staffing shortages, but because of the shutdown, fifty-three percent of delays had been caused by understaffing. The author uses this as evidence that the problem is national, not local.

Next is a Reuters story titled ~3,500 controllers. The article text is also not available here, but the author's commentary supplies the key number: the FAA is short about 3,500 controllers. That forces the rest into mandatory overtime, six days a week, and during the shutdown, sometimes without pay. The author's larger point is that this is a poorly incentivized system, and it is absurd for a mission-critical service to be financed by annual appropriations subject to political failure.

Then there is a New York Times piece titled sometimes without pay! The article reports that controllers missed their first full paycheck of the shutdown, and both union leaders and the transportation secretary warned of serious consequences if they missed another. The nearly eleven thousand controllers have become the face of the shutdown because they are required to stay on the job without pay. The piece describes controllers in yellow union shirts fanning out at major airports, handing passengers pamphlets and urging them to contact their representatives. The union president said controllers now have to focus on paying for gas, child care, and taking care of their children, which makes the system less safe. The author's commentary uses this as the human strain behind the staffing crisis.

After establishing the U.S. failure, the post turns to the Canadian model. The next link is a Transport Canada page titled NAV CANADA. It describes NAV CANADA as a private, not-for-profit organization established in 1996, self-financing, receiving no government support, and relying on fees charged to users. Its board has fifteen directors: four elected by commercial carriers, one by business and general aviation, three by the government, two by employee unions, and four independent directors. The author says Canada fixed this in 1996 by spinning off air navigation services to NAV CANADA, a private, non-profit utility funded by user fees, not taxes. Safety regulation stayed with the government, while operations moved to a professionally governed, bond-financed utility with multi-year budgets.

The next link is a NAV CANADA blog post titled more accurate and safer satellite-based navigation. It explains the benefits of space-based ADS-B surveillance over the North Atlantic, the world's busiest oceanic airspace. Traditional ground-based surveillance covered only thirty percent of the globe, and outside radar coverage controllers relied on position updates every ten to fourteen minutes. With space-based ADS-B, any equipped aircraft can be tracked anywhere on earth, all day, every day. The blog says longitudinal separation standards were reduced, overall safety risks are expected to fall by about seventy-six percent, and carbon dioxide emissions are estimated to drop by about two tonnes per oceanic flight. The author's point is that NAV CANADA has been instrumental in moving Canada to more accurate and safer satellite-based navigation, rather than relying on ground-based radar as the United States does.

The final link, also titled NAV CANADA, comes from NAV CANADA's own explanation of space-based ADS-B. It notes that NAV CANADA, in conjunction with the United Kingdom's NATS, was the first in the world to deploy space-based ADS-B, implementing it in 2019 over the North Atlantic. It was also the first air navigation service provider worldwide to implement space-based ADS-B in its domestic airspace. The page describes a receiver network hosted on the Iridium NEXT satellite constellation of sixty-six satellites, which receives position and altitude broadcasts from aircraft transponders. It lists benefits including improved emergency response, more flexible and efficient use of airspace, shorter flight times, and reduced fuel consumption. The author quotes the world-first claim to show that the Canadian model delivers modernization while the U.S. NextGen effort has delivered only a fraction of its promised benefits.

Taken together, the links build one argument: the U.S. air traffic system is mission-critical but financed through annual appropriations and political failure, while Canada's user-fee, board-governed utility aligns power with incentives. The author's proposed remedy is to copy Canada's model, put airline executives on the board, and let them tax themselves to benefit themselves. As the author puts it, align power with incentives and performance will follow. That is the case made in Privatize Air Traffic Control, Redux.

  1. Privatize Air Traffic Control, Redux
  2. October of 2025
  3. grounded flights at Reagan (DCA)
  4. thousands of flights
  5. major airports across the country
  6. ~3,500 controllers
  7. sometimes without pay!
  8. NAV CANADA
  9. more accurate and safer satellite-based navigation
  10. NAV CANADA