Listen: https://serve.buildtall.systems/a84b2047c10a4d838398997b4db26f7e2381bd5d55f6fb5cbbe06e1ef9c2c7a8.mp3
This episode of marginal revolution read out covers the post Do not overrate zero-sum status-seeking. The post takes up a question that sounds abstract but shows up everywhere: do people mostly want to be richer in absolute terms, or do they mostly want to outrank others? The author pushes back against the view that life is mostly status competition, and the linked pieces build the case with real-world behavior rather than survey answers.
The first linked article, Do not overrate zero-sum status-seeking, is the post itself, and it lays out the core argument. The author asks: if people really preferred relatively higher income in a poorer society, then people born in Western Europe and the United States would be saving up their money so they could live like kings in Africa. Very few middle-class or upper-class people in poor countries would try to get to the West. But what we actually observe is precisely the opposite. Doctors from Africa come to America in order to drive a cab if their license to practice medicine is not recognized. Research on Middle Eastern and African migrants to Europe shows that they are not the poorest of the poor; they are relatively well off for where they come from. There are also many stories about how terribly South Asian migrant workers are treated in the Arab Gulf, but this causes no problem in recruiting laborers who want to earn a higher income. This is not a laboratory question; it is the kind of choice people make with their feet. The author treats migration as a revealed preference test, and the examples all point the same way. The author's point is that real behavior, not hypothetical questions, reveals that people are willing to accept lower relative status in a richer society to gain higher absolute income.
Next comes a link titled shows. This article could not be retrieved, so the only material available is the author's commentary. The author uses it as evidence for the migration point just made: research on Middle Eastern and African migrants to Europe shows that the people moving are relatively well off rather than the poorest of the poor. The title suggests the link is offered as a direct demonstration of that selection effect, but beyond that, the text of the article itself is not available, and this episode does not fill in what it might contain.
The final link is more from Richard Hanania. This points to an essay by Richard Hanania titled No, People Wouldn't Rather Have Higher Relative Income in a Poorer Society. The essay begins by engaging with Noah Carl's claim that life is mostly status competition. It cites a famous 1998 study in which Harvard students and faculty were asked whether they would prefer a world where they earn fifty thousand dollars and others earn twenty-five thousand, or a world where they earn one hundred thousand dollars and others earn two hundred thousand, with prices held constant. Between thirty-eight and fifty-six percent said they preferred the lower income as long as they earned more than others. Hanania's response is that such experiments are fine, but nothing is on the line, so people can give strange answers for all sorts of reasons. The results need to be checked against real-world behavior. Then he gives the same real-world argument the author quoted: if relative income in a poorer society were truly preferred, Westerners would save up and live like kings in Africa, doctors from Africa would not come to the United States to drive cabs, and abused South Asian workers would stop going to the Gulf. He adds a possible objection: maybe people care about the reference group of the country they come from. A poor Mexican day laborer in the United States may be looked down upon in his new home, but everyone in his home village sees him as a big shot. Similarly, people criticize passport bros who take American dollars and spend them on prostitutes in Thailand. It is a paid post, but the available excerpt contains the full thrust. The excerpt ends there, at the paywall, but the author's commentary is simply that there is more from Richard Hanania.
Across the three links, the theme is consistent: do not overrate zero-sum status-seeking. The post, the underlying research on migrant selection, and Hanania's essay all push toward revealed preferences over survey answers. If people valued relative position above all, migration would flow the other way. Instead, people move toward higher absolute income even when it costs them status. That tension between experimental results and real-world behavior is what makes this post worth reading.
