↵ select ↓ ↑ navigate esc close

marginal revolution read out: The Everywhere Rent Seekers

marginal revolution read out ·

Listen: https://serve.buildtall.systems/1e3578e6d65d21dc7cd8fa9c0689bc53d333cfdef5317f8bf68dca04d777597e.mp3

Source: https://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2026/11/the-everywhere-rent-seekers.html?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_campaign=the-everywhere-rent-seekers


marginal revolution read out covers the post The Everywhere Rent Seekers from Marginal Revolution. The post looks at where economic and political power really sits, and it argues that the most important rent seekers are not the famous billionaires but the many millionaires spread across nearly every congressional district.

The first linked article is titled The Everywhere Rent Seekers, and it is the Marginal Revolution post itself. The author begins by pointing to a good post from Owen Zidar and Eric Zwick on the political power of billionaires versus the power of many millionaires, based on their book The Everywhere Millionaire. Zidar and Zwick put the scale of billionaire wealth in perspective. Even at very frothy public market valuations, the Forbes list amounts to around eight trillion dollars, or roughly four point three percent of total household wealth. Meanwhile, Everywhere Millionaires are probably worth more than sixty-three trillion dollars, or thirty-eight percent of total household wealth. These are the dentists, car dealers and mid-size business owners. The author says Zidar and Zwick also argue that the power of billionaires is often exaggerated relative to the power of millionaires who have both money and votes. They give the example of Elon Musk. The author summarizes their point: Elon did not want the massive tax cuts in the OBBBA extended, because they did not go to tech billionaires. He did not benefit from reduced EV demand when the EV credits were abolished. He benefited little from the new deduction for car loan interest, since financing car purchases is a small part of Tesla's business. The people who drove those changes and reaped the rewards were the Everywhere Millionaire car dealers, who reside in nearly every congressional district and often represent them directly.

Then the author adds his own sharper example. He says all of that is correct, but there is an even more telling and absurd asymmetry. In many states it is illegal for Tesla to sell its cars directly to consumers. The list includes Alabama, Arkansas, Connecticut, Iowa, Kansas, Louisiana, Montana, Nebraska, New Mexico, North Dakota, Oklahoma, South Carolina, South Dakota, Texas, West Virginia and Wisconsin. The author is especially struck that Texas is on the list. Tesla builds the Model Y in Austin, but the company cannot sell directly to Texans. A Texan must technically buy the car from Tesla in another state. The author says that shows the power of the everywhere rent seekers.

The second article is titled good post. It is the Substack piece by Owen Zidar and Eric Zwick that the author recommends. The subtitle says Krugman is the GOAT, but even GOATs have blind spots. Zidar and Zwick say they were thrilled to see Paul Krugman engage with their work, and they credit his writing as an inspiration. But they think his view of the American economy and political system misses an important part of the picture. They focus on pass-through businesses. Krugman wrote that most U.S. businesses are pass-throughs, and that most of them are not real businesses like car dealerships or restaurants, but basically legal fictions created for tax purposes. Zidar and Zwick respond that pass-through businesses account for nearly half of employment, and their industrial mix is more representative of the American economy than traditional corporations. In their research and book, auto dealers and restaurants are some of the biggest generators of top pass-through profits. Auto dealers rank number three in their list of four-digit pass-through profit-generating industries with top-one-percent owners.

Zidar and Zwick also take on Krugman's claims about corporate tax collections. Krugman says corporate tax revenue has dwindled to near insignificance relative to GDP. Zidar and Zwick agree that corporate tax collections are at all-time lows, and that some of this reflects lower rates and multinational avoidance. But they say an equally important part is the migration of business activity away from the corporate tax base and into pass-through taxation. Without recognizing that shift, Krugman misses changes in the personal income tax as a driver of falling taxes on business activity and current structural deficits. They add that loopholes encourage skilled workers to become business owners, which causes an increasing share of labor income to masquerade as capital for tax purposes. They cite Matt Yglesias's example that pass-through structures are commonly used by high-earning Substack writers, so most of their income is not subject to payroll taxation.

Zidar and Zwick connect this to the decline of the labor share of income. They argue that an important part of the decline is tax-induced relabeling of labor income, both in the pass-through sector and in stock-based compensation at public companies. The remaining decline is concentrated in manufacturing. They agree with Krugman that billionaire wealth has risen dramatically, but they return to the comparison: the Forbes list is about eight trillion dollars, while Everywhere Millionaires are probably worth more than sixty-three trillion dollars. They also make a political point. They are not aware of any Everywhere Millionaires who have the power to shut off internet on the front lines in Ukraine. Scrutinizing anti-democratic power is essential, but they warn against blaming every policy failure on a small number of billionaires and absolving everybody else. The power to legislate still resides with Congress, and the power to regulate many markets is reserved for states and localities. They close with the Elon example again: the car dealers reap the rewards while Elon loses big in the midterm despite spending half a billion dollars.

The third article is The Everywhere Millionaire. This is the book by Owen Zidar and Eric Zwick that the author recommends. The retrieved page is only Amazon's shopping interface, so there is no additional text from the book itself to draw on. The author describes it as an excellent book, and the earlier discussion makes clear that it develops the argument about pass-through businesses, tax relabeling, and the political power of distributed millionaire wealth.

Taken together, the links make a consistent argument. Attention usually goes to the very richest and most visible people, but policy often reflects the interests of a much larger and more locally embedded group. The Tesla direct-sales example makes that abstract point concrete: a company can build cars in Texas and still be blocked from selling them directly to Texans by the political power of car dealers. The discussion closes on that theme of visible billionaires versus the everywhere rent seekers who shape the rules in quieter ways.

  1. The Everywhere Rent Seekers
  2. good post
  3. The Everywhere Millionaire