↵ select ↓ ↑ navigate esc close

The Fall of Our Discontent

Andrew Yang Newsletter ·

Americans are mad. It’s showing up in the numbers and anywhere you look. 55 percent of Americans think their personal finances are deteriorating. People can’t save money. Inflation is stubborn. Real wages, adjusted for inflation, have been negative since April of this year, a span of 6 months.

This is translating to deep dissatisfaction with Trump, Republicans and the folks currently in power. One commentator noted that Trump ran on 3 promises: curbing inflation, enforcing immigration laws (without shooting Americans) and no new wars. “Even the densest voter can tell when you go 0 for 3.” The war in Iran is an easy thing to blame for elevated gas prices. It doesn’t help that Trump seems way more preoccupied with personally profiting and building ballrooms than actually making progress on any of the above issues. His approval rating stands at a dismal 32%. This is WAY below the water line and historically aberrant.

Midterms are almost always bad for the incumbent party even when things aren’t quite this extreme. Throw in AI shaking Americans’ sense of the future and you get a recipe for blowout losses, even though the map favored Republicans going in, particularly for the Senate. Democrats have hopes of winning in states like Texas, Iowa, Ohio and Kansas, and Republicans recently spent some money in ruby red South Carolina defending the Senate seat there (our old friend Jermaine Johnson is running for Governor in SC and making a push too). Even states like Idaho and South Dakota are in play because the Democrats stepped aside and let Todd Achilles and Brian Bengs challenge for the seats; each has raised over $1 million in previously noncompetitive states and is polling neck-and-neck with the 83-year-old and 72-year-old incumbents.

Republicans were hoping that their money advantage would insulate them from challenges; they had a $125 million to $15 million advantage between the RNC vs. the DNC for example. Trump’s PAC reported $415 million on hand, a massive war chest. But the money gets spent on ads and people still don’t like them. Campaign spending is a funny thing; it can amplify your message and clue in uninformed voters. It can elevate the negatives of your opponent. It can introduce you. But if voters are mad enough, they can figure out who the incumbent is.

By the way, worth noting is that to the extent big money is being spent by the Dems, it’s on Congress. Competitive gubernatorial races in places like Florida (and another old friend, David Jolly) are being neglected by the megadonor class. Getting Dems to try and put a check on Trump is an easy sell. Much harder to care about flipping Tallahassee, though these two things are going to intersect eventually. Republicans have been better at winning state races while Democrats are somewhat fixated on D.C.

People ask me all the time how I think it plays out. I do think we are going to see a breakthrough in one or more of the red states; I’ve met James Talarico (Texas), Adam Hamilton (Kansas) and Sherrod Brown (Ohio) and can easily see them winning their races. I think you’re going to see an Independent Senator emerge, whether from Idaho, South Dakota or Nebraska, which will be an enormous deal. Democrats are poised to have a great night on November 3rd from a national perspective. I see them winning the House and achieving a 50-50 Senate or even a slight majority, which would represent a gain of several seats.

The main unanswered question then becomes, “Will the Trump crew actually acknowledge defeat and hand the keys of Congress back to the Dems?” It’s hard for me to see that happening. We are well beyond the “Well, we got shellacked, we’ll get them next time” version of American politics. The current identity of the Republican Party is that their opponents are degenerate threats to the country, and you don’t surrender power to those sorts of people over something like a vote total. Maybe the votes are a hallucination. My fear for years has been a muddied process, accusations of fraud, a failure to seat winners, invocation of security threats and the like. A fog of mistrust is descending. I’ll be pleasantly shocked if the January after the midterm is clean and orderly.

Our institutions aren’t exactly clicking – more like hanging on by a thread or dissolving before our eyes.

Let’s say the election stands up and Congress does revert to the Dems - what gets done? I’d expect very little happens legislatively as Republicans would still be able to filibuster from the Senate and Trump could veto anything he doesn’t like. The Dem 2028 field will start declaring itself shortly after the midterms, and the political spotlight will then turn to them. Kamala Harris recently hired 9 political operatives and staffers – a strong sign that she may be prepping for a third run. I think that’s a terrible idea, but she will hoover up a ton of energy, attention and money from the rest of the field if she does run.

I, personally, am animated by the prospect of getting middle-of-the-road, independent, pragmatic Senators out of Idaho and South Dakota – what a message that would send. Todd Achilles and Brian Bengs are both military veterans and former college instructors. Even one of them making it to the Senate would signal a different kind of politics, and their votes could be pivotal in a closely divided Congress. I’ve donated to both of them and hope you do too.

Dems may claim that Americans have faith in them again because of a good result in November. A friend said to me, “Well, the pendulum is swinging, and you get the sense it will go farther and farther each time.” The truth is that Americans are simply grasping for answers to a diminishing way of life. Our discontent will continue until something truly new emerges.

I interview Liam Petry, the creator of Find My Politics this week on Podcast. To check out Forward Party candidates including Todd Achilles, Seth Bodnar, and Brian Bengs, click here. New polls have Todd Achilles and Brian Bengs tied with the incumbents! For 3 months off your mobile bill with Noble Mobile, click here or email matt@noblemobile.com and use my name to switch or explore. It will save you money and time – hundreds of dollars for the average American. Look up.