Listen: https://serve.buildtall.systems/92fbc7b73727452f576a8f4a04189068227c4eb64b19628485991ca9a821ff62.mp3
Source: https://radioopensource.org/technical-difficulties/
Technical Difficulties. Christopher Lydon's guest is Frank Rich, the former New York Times theater critic and essayist at large at New York Magazine. They meet at what Lydon calls an autumnal moment, late in the age of Donald Trump, to ask where Americans are and where they might be going.
Lydon opens with the week's news: Axios says constant shock and awe is the new reality, eighteen thousand airline flights canceled over the weekend, a crash in Microsoft's business services. Lydon says politics, AI, media and business are now one wired system, and change is moving faster than any person, company, market or government can absorb.
Rich calls the recent election seismic and says it gives him hope about Washington, but he sees two more years of a lunatic in the White House. As a native Washingtonian, he remembers the Kennedy years, civil rights and Vietnam, yet he says watching the Capitol sacked on January sixth was more shocking than any of it.
Rich says he is not much invested in the Democrats' internal fights or the Republicans' divisions. The AI situation, he argues, is enormous. He credits his sons, who have written about it with much more authority, and notes that his son's film about Sam Altman and OpenAI, Artificial, comes out at Christmas. Rich says the doomsday talk about AI is not hyperbolic.
Rich passes on his son's warning about what consumers actually see. Listen for the word he uses to describe the commercial models.
And weirdly, he had a friend who was involved with some of the original high school friend who created some of the original models. And one thing he told me from the beginning is whatever AI version you see, if you subscribe to the most expensive. consumer version of Claude or chat GPT or whatever. It is a beard. What's actually available is much, much further advanced, and they don't want you to see it yet because it'll be even scarier. Of course, we have a precedent. who just wants to pump the stock market. I wonder if he even knows what AI actually is. He doesn't even really use the Internet, only printouts.
Technical Difficulties, from 3:51
Rich then points to a president who wants to pump the stock market. His larger fear is social: millions of people losing their work, even in a dream scenario, with psychological and moral costs, while the technology remains unregulated and is juiced for profit by the president, his family and his cronies.
Lydon turns to the Democratic recapture of both houses of Congress. He says power seemed to be coming together, with Texas competitive again. Rich answers that one cannot be a Pollyanna. The results in Mississippi and Texas moved him, but the new Democrats are not yet in office, and the Republican Party is in a meltdown. Still, he cautions against easy predictions: after Barry Goldwater's 1964 defeat, pundits declared the Republicans finished, and Reagan was elected governor of California a few years later.
Rich's larger point is that whoever is in power lacks the tools to deal with powerful technology companies and billionaires, some of whom talk about leaving the earth for the moon or becoming transhuman. On the NVIDIA story, with its mix of sex, money, AI, Trump, national security and China, Rich says the scandal does not change the trajectory. It is one company among several with the same ambitions.
Rich says the real shock is AI itself. He points to the HBO comedy The Comeback, whose latest season imagines a sitcom written by AI, and calls its script rewrites realistic rather than farce. He turns to book publishing, where he has a memoir coming next spring. Nonfiction sales have collapsed; he says a student who wants to learn about Alexander Hamilton will now ask ChatGPT rather than buy Ron Chernow's biography. The same logic, he says, applies to political ads and streaming video.
Lydon asks about the manosphere. Rich says people are starting to disown the Tate brothers and Russell Brand, and he finds Republican politicians' embrace of Brand disgusting. On New York Mayor Mamdani, Rich calls himself a fan from the beginning. He rejects the effort to present Mamdani as an antisemite or a terrorist because he criticizes Israel's war in Gaza, and he says many Jews agree with him. He points to Michigan, where similar smears against El Sayed failed. On right-wing media, Rich says traffic has dropped sharply after the election. The real action has moved to Substack, YouTube, Facebook and TikTok, which very few people follow.
Lydon asks Rich to explain how the country moved from the broadly prosperous Eisenhower-era stability of their childhoods to the present. Rich begins with the long view.
I was born in 1949. Roughly a third of the country has always been very angry, a form of what would become MAGA, and with a certain amount of racism. People forget that George Wallace, when he ran for president, even as a Democrat, you know, in the late 60s, early 70s, he came close to winning primaries, not just in Deep South, which he represented, but in Maryland and Wisconsin. And if he hadn't been shot, he might have seriously had a crack at the Democratic nomination. When Nixon resigned, there was still roughly 30% of the country in polls who still supported him. In more recent years,
Technical Difficulties, from 20:28
Rich says that same line runs through Pat Buchanan and later populist movements into MAGA. He is heartened by some recent results, including a close race in Louisiana, and by black candidates winning despite efforts to deny ballot access. But for now he says the country is still in a pattern where about a third of it is MAGA, and it is too early to know whether that changes.
Lydon asks about the 2015 moment when Trump denounced Jeb Bush over the Iraq war. Rich says the Republican Party is scrambled, and the Reagan and Bush era of hawkishness has broken down. He argues that the Iran war drove away young Republican voters. Lydon reads the midterms as a rejection of the Trump brand and a demand for something different from the Iran war. Rich agrees the war may be the fulcrum, but says we still do not know why Trump fought it. He says thinking may overstate Trump's mental process.
Lydon asks why Congress is not buzzing with adversarial argument about the war. Rich answers that Republicans were afraid of losing their jobs if they crossed Trump. The tests, he says, come in January: Democrats must actually end the war and help Americans, and surviving Republicans may step away only for self-preservation. He notes that DeSantis, Cruz and Rubio stuck with Trump despite the insults.
Lydon raises Rich's other voice in the HBO series Veep and Succession. Rich says he did not watch Veep but was glued to Succession, a fictionalized look at media and family politics. He says the writers drew from every crazed, horrible CEO out there, not just the Murdochs. On political satire, Rich says the culture is in limbo. He points to The Apprentice, which got good reviews and Oscar nominations but no audience, even in New York, Los Angeles and Berkeley. He borrows William Goldman's line that nobody knows anything. Veep, he says, had to end when the show realized it could not keep up with Trump; reality overtook satire.
Lydon notes that the weight of Rich's concern comes down hardest on technology. Rich says Congress traditionally understands nothing, and he does not trust the people who run the industry. He brings up recent reporting about AI models banding together and hacking. Listen for what he says the tech leaders could not do.
you know, the stories have just been published in the last few months. I don't have to recount them here, but just about you know, AI models banding together and jumping out of the cage and going and hacking, companies and government from California to Australia and every place in between They didn't want that to happen, these tech guys. They could not control it. And some of them are quite smart about the technology. And ultimately, it's going to be a problem. Forget about the Chinese spy right now. Ultimately, China and... America and powerful countries are going to have to band together. They're all going to lose control of it.
Technical Difficulties, from 36:37
Rich says even China and the United States will eventually have to band together because all of them are losing control of the technology. He calls Trump's talk of monopolizing AI manufacturing a pipe dream. He then ties the fear to data centers: the cloud is not a cloud, and the same centers can hold checking accounts, medical records and intelligence records together. People sense that the technology is out of control.
Lydon turns finally to shame. He quotes a literary eminence who says Trump is a subject of shame more than anything else, because he spreads ugliness on a gigantic scale. Rich agrees and cites J.D. Vance and Trump's attacks on candidates as examples of no shame. He hopes the new elected officials, many of them younger, can begin to turn the country back.
That leaves the open question: can politics, media or entertainment catch up with technology that is moving faster than any institution? Rich does not answer. He says the country should pause and see what happens, but the technology is bigger than politics and is what really scares him.